Skip to content

You are using an outdated browser. Please upgrade your browser to improve your experience and security.

For many separating couples, determining who keeps the family pet(s) can be one of the most emotional issues arising from the breakdown of a relationship. Yet, historically, the law has offered a relatively simple answer: a dog is property.

In Alberta, that remains the law. However, recent decisions suggest that the analysis is becoming more nuanced. Courts are increasingly recognizing the obvious difficulty in treating a companion animal in precisely the same manner as a vehicle, piece of furniture, or other household property.

The Traditional Approach: Who Owns the Dog?

Because animals are property at law, disputes over pets have traditionally been approached as questions of ownership rather than “custody.”

That distinction matters. When parents disagree about where a child should live, the court applies the best-interests-of-the-child test. There is presently no equivalent statutory test for family pets in Alberta.

Instead, the question is fundamentally one of ownership: who acquired the animal, what agreements existed between the parties, and what does the evidence establish about
ownership?

That can produce an uncomfortable disconnect between the legal characterization of an animal and the role that animal actually played within a family.

Singh v Smith

The Alberta Court of King’s Bench recently considered that disconnect in Singh v Smith, 2025 ABKB 715. The case concerned four cats acquired by the parties during their relationship. Following their separation, both parties sought exclusive possession of all 4 animals. At first instance, the Alberta Court of Justice found that the parties jointly owned the cats and ultimately divided them between the parties, with each retaining two.

On appeal, the Court of King’s Bench was asked to consider, among other things, whether the dispute should be determined by reference to the “best interests” of the animals.

The Court declined to go that far.

Unlike British Columbia, Alberta has not enacted legislation directing courts to consider the welfare or best interests of a companion animal when spouses separate. The Court also cautioned against importing principles developed for parenting disputes into disputes involving animals. Parenthood and pet ownership remain legally distinct concepts.

But that was not the end of the analysis.

Property, But Not Quite Like Other Property

Although Singh confirms that companion animals remain property in Alberta, the decision reflects the development of a more contextual approach to determining ownership.

Rather than asking only whose name appears on a receipt, courts may consider the circumstances surrounding the animal throughout the parties’ relationship.

Relevant considerations can include how the animal was acquired, whether there was an express or implied agreement regarding ownership, who exercised primary possession, who bore the majority of expenses and what occurred following separation.

In Singh, the Court of Appeal ultimately upheld the finding that the parties jointly owned the four cats and the decision to divide them equally.

The significance of the case may therefore lie less in changing the legal classification of animals and more in recognizing that traditional concepts of ownership require some adaptation when the “property” in question is a living animal.

Alberta Compared With British Columbia

Alberta’s approach is particularly interesting when compared with British Columbia.

British Columbia has legislatively recognized companion animals as a distinct category when family property is divided. Its legislation permits courts to consider factors relating to the animal itself and the parties’ relationship with it.

Alberta has not yet taken that step.

In Singh, the Court specifically recognized the absence of comparable Alberta legislation. Unless Alberta’s Legislature intervenes, or a higher court develops the common law further, disputes over companion animals will continue to be decided primarily through property and ownership principles.

What Does This Mean for Separating Pet Owners?

For Alberta pet owners, documentation still matters.

Purchase and adoption records, licensing, microchip registration and veterinary records may all provide evidence relevant to ownership. But Singh demonstrates why the analysis may extend beyond whose name appears on a particular document. Evidence regarding the parties’ intentions, financial contributions, care of the animal and possession following separation may also become relevant.

Couples can also address these issues themselves. Cohabitation agreements and separation agreements can specify who will retain an animal, how expenses will be handled and, where both parties wish to remain involved, what that arrangement will look like.

An Area of Law Still Developing

Alberta has not adopted a “best interests of the dog” test, nor has it transformed pet disputes into custody proceedings.

For now, dogs, cats and other companion animals remain property.

But Singh v Smith illustrates that describing an animal as property does not necessarily mean treating it exactly like every other piece of property. Courts are increasingly confronting the reality that companion animals occupy a unique position: legally owned, but emotionally and practically part of the family.

Whether Alberta ultimately follows British Columbia and formally recognizes that distinction in legislation remains to be seen.

Great experience. Professional and thoughtful with good insights.
Relaxed and to the point team. Helped me when I panicked to stay calm and then walked me through things. Really friendly and always available
Very satisfied with the services provided by the lawyers at SVR Lawyers! It was a long and convoluted divorce process, but Cindy Lee and their assistants have helped me to navigate through it and finalize it. I highly recommend them!
J.B., Client

Find the right lawyer for you